Comparing OAuth 2.0 Flows — Authorization Code vs Client Credentials

Complete comparison of OAuth 2.0 flows with sequence diagrams, implementation examples, and use cases

Introduction

OAuth 2.0 defines multiple authentication flows (grant types) for different use cases. The two primary flows you'll use in modern applications are Authorization Code for user authentication and Client Credentials for machine-to-machine communication. Understanding when and how to use each flow is essential for building secure, scalable applications.

This guide provides a comprehensive comparison of these flows with practical implementation examples, sequence diagrams, and real-world use cases. We'll show you how to document OAuth flows using AutEng's markdown, Mermaid diagrams, and code examples.

Quick Decision Guide

Use Authorization Code when:
  • • You need to authenticate users
  • • Your application acts on behalf of users
  • • You're building web apps, mobile apps, or SPAs
Use Client Credentials when:
  • • No user is involved (machine-to-machine)
  • • Your application acts on its own behalf
  • • You're building backend services or API clients

Authorization Code Flow

The Authorization Code flow is the most secure OAuth 2.0 flow for user authentication. It's designed for applications where users need to grant permission for the app to access their data. The flow involves redirecting users to an authorization server, where they authenticate and grant consent.

Complete Flow Diagram

Here's how the Authorization Code flow works from start to finish. Notice how the authorization code is exchanged for tokens on the backend, keeping the client secret secure.

Authorization Code Flow - Complete Sequence

User authentication with secure token exchange on the backend

Rendering diagram...

Key Benefits

  • Most Secure: Client secret never exposed to browser or user
  • User Consent: Users explicitly grant permissions to your application
  • Refresh Tokens: Long-lived sessions without requiring re-authentication
  • CSRF Protection: State parameter prevents cross-site request forgery
  • PKCE Support: Can be enhanced with PKCE for public clients (SPAs, mobile apps)

Perfect For

  • • Web applications with backend servers
  • • Mobile applications (with PKCE extension)
  • • Single-page applications (with PKCE extension)
  • • Any application that needs to act on behalf of a user
  • • Applications requiring long-lived access via refresh tokens

Implementation Example

Here's a practical implementation of the Authorization Code flow in Python and TypeScript, showing how to handle the complete authentication process including token refresh.

Authorization Code Flow Implementation

Complete implementation with automatic token refresh

from flask import Flask, redirect, request, session, url_for
import requests
import secrets

app = Flask(__name__)
app.secret_key = 'your-secret-key'

# OAuth configuration
AUTH_URL = 'https://auth.example.com/authorize'
TOKEN_URL = 'https://auth.example.com/token'
CLIENT_ID = 'your_client_id'
CLIENT_SECRET = 'your_client_secret'
REDIRECT_URI = 'http://localhost:5000/callback'

@app.route('/login')
def login():
    # Generate random state for CSRF protection
    state = secrets.token_urlsafe(32)
    session['oauth_state'] = state
    
    # Build authorization URL
    params = {
        'response_type': 'code',
        'client_id': CLIENT_ID,
        'redirect_uri': REDIRECT_URI,
        'scope': 'read write',
        'state': state
    }
    
    auth_url = f"{AUTH_URL}?{'&'.join(f'{k}={v}' for k, v in params.items())}"
    return redirect(auth_url)

@app.route('/callback')
def callback():
    # Verify state to prevent CSRF
    if request.args.get('state') != session.get('oauth_state'):
        return 'Invalid state parameter', 400
    
    # Exchange authorization code for tokens
    code = request.args.get('code')
    token_data = {
        'grant_type': 'authorization_code',
        'code': code,
        'client_id': CLIENT_ID,
        'client_secret': CLIENT_SECRET,
        'redirect_uri': REDIRECT_URI
    }
    
    response = requests.post(TOKEN_URL, data=token_data)
    tokens = response.json()
    
    # Store tokens in session
    session['access_token'] = tokens['access_token']
    session['refresh_token'] = tokens['refresh_token']
    
    return redirect(url_for('dashboard'))

@app.route('/dashboard')
def dashboard():
    if 'access_token' not in session:
        return redirect(url_for('login'))
    
    # Use access token to call API
    headers = {'Authorization': f"Bearer {session['access_token']}"}
    response = requests.get('https://api.example.com/user', headers=headers)
    
    return f"User data: {response.json()}"

@app.route('/refresh')
def refresh():
    # Refresh access token using refresh token
    token_data = {
        'grant_type': 'refresh_token',
        'refresh_token': session['refresh_token'],
        'client_id': CLIENT_ID,
        'client_secret': CLIENT_SECRET
    }
    
    response = requests.post(TOKEN_URL, data=token_data)
    tokens = response.json()
    
    session['access_token'] = tokens['access_token']
    if 'refresh_token' in tokens:
        session['refresh_token'] = tokens['refresh_token']
    
    return 'Token refreshed successfully'

PKCE Extension

Proof Key for Code Exchange (PKCE, pronounced "pixie") is an extension that makes Authorization Code flow secure for public clients like mobile apps and single-page applications that can't securely store a client secret.

PKCE adds a dynamically generated code verifier and code challenge to prevent authorization code interception attacks. It's now recommended for all OAuth 2.0 clients, even those with a backend server.

Client Credentials Flow

The Client Credentials flow is designed for machine-to-machine (M2M) authentication where no user is involved. This is the simplest OAuth 2.0 flow - the client directly authenticates with the authorization server using its credentials and receives an access token.

Complete Flow Diagram

The Client Credentials flow is straightforward: authenticate with credentials, receive a token, use the token to access APIs. No user interaction or browser redirects are involved.

Client Credentials Flow - Complete Sequence

Direct server-to-server authentication without user involvement

Rendering diagram...

Key Benefits

  • Simplest Flow: Direct credential exchange with no redirects or user interaction
  • High Performance: Minimal overhead, perfect for high-volume API access
  • Secure: Credentials stored securely on backend servers only
  • Scope-Based: Fine-grained access control through scopes
  • Easy to Implement: Simple HTTP POST request to get tokens

Perfect For

  • • Microservices communicating with each other
  • • Backend services and daemons
  • • CLI tools and scripts
  • • Scheduled jobs and cron tasks
  • • IoT devices and sensors
  • • Data integration and ETL pipelines

Implementation Example

Here's a production-ready implementation with automatic token caching and refresh. The client manages token expiration automatically, ensuring your API calls always use valid tokens.

Client Credentials Flow Implementation

Production-ready implementation with automatic token management

import requests
import time
from typing import Optional

class OAuth2Client:
    """OAuth 2.0 Client Credentials client with automatic token management."""
    
    def __init__(self, token_url: str, client_id: str, client_secret: str):
        self.token_url = token_url
        self.client_id = client_id
        self.client_secret = client_secret
        self.access_token: Optional[str] = None
        self.token_expires_at: float = 0
    
    def get_access_token(self) -> str:
        """Get a valid access token, refreshing if necessary."""
        # Return cached token if still valid
        if self.access_token and time.time() < self.token_expires_at:
            return self.access_token
        
        # Request new token
        response = requests.post(
            self.token_url,
            data={
                'grant_type': 'client_credentials',
                'client_id': self.client_id,
                'client_secret': self.client_secret,
                'scope': 'read write'
            },
            headers={'Content-Type': 'application/x-www-form-urlencoded'}
        )
        response.raise_for_status()
        
        token_data = response.json()
        self.access_token = token_data['access_token']
        # Set expiry with 60 second buffer
        self.token_expires_at = time.time() + token_data['expires_in'] - 60
        
        return self.access_token
    
    def call_api(self, api_url: str, method: str = 'GET', **kwargs) -> dict:
        """Make an authenticated API call with automatic retry on token expiration."""
        token = self.get_access_token()
        headers = kwargs.pop('headers', {})
        headers['Authorization'] = f'Bearer {token}'
        
        response = requests.request(method, api_url, headers=headers, **kwargs)
        
        # Retry once if token expired
        if response.status_code == 401:
            self.access_token = None  # Force token refresh
            token = self.get_access_token()
            headers['Authorization'] = f'Bearer {token}'
            response = requests.request(method, api_url, headers=headers, **kwargs)
        
        response.raise_for_status()
        return response.json()

# Usage example
client = OAuth2Client(
    token_url='https://auth.example.com/oauth/token',
    client_id='your_client_id',
    client_secret='your_client_secret'
)

# Make API calls - token management is automatic
data = client.call_api('https://api.example.com/resources')
print(data)

# Create a resource
new_resource = client.call_api(
    'https://api.example.com/resources',
    method='POST',
    json={'name': 'New Resource'}
)
print(new_resource)

Security Best Practices

  • Store credentials securely: Use environment variables or secrets managers (AWS Secrets Manager, HashiCorp Vault)
  • Use HTTPS only: Never send credentials or tokens over unencrypted connections
  • Implement token caching: Reuse tokens until they expire to reduce load on auth server
  • Use minimal scopes: Request only the permissions your application needs
  • Rotate secrets regularly: Change client secrets periodically (e.g., every 90 days)
  • Monitor access patterns: Log authentication events and watch for suspicious activity

Side-by-Side Comparison

Here's a comprehensive comparison to help you choose the right OAuth 2.0 flow for your application:

FeatureAuthorization CodeClient Credentials
User Involvement✅ Yes - user authenticates and grants consent❌ No - machine-to-machine only
Client Secret Required✅ Yes (or PKCE for public clients)✅ Yes - must be kept confidential
Refresh Tokens✅ Yes - enables long-lived sessions❌ No - request new access token when expired
Token Exposure🔒 Secure - tokens handled on backend🔒 Secure - backend only
Security Level🟢 High - most secure for user auth🟢 High - when used correctly
Implementation Complexity🟡 Medium - requires backend and redirects🟢 Low - simple direct exchange
Best Use CaseWeb apps, mobile apps, SPAs with usersBackend services, APIs, CLIs, automation
Typical Token LifetimeAccess: 15-60 min, Refresh: days/weeksAccess: 1-24 hours (no refresh)

Choosing the Right Flow

Choose Authorization Code when:
  • • Your application has users who need to log in
  • • You need to access user-specific data or act on behalf of users
  • • You want long-lived sessions with refresh tokens
  • • You're building a web app, mobile app, or SPA
Choose Client Credentials when:
  • • No user is involved in the authentication process
  • • Your application acts on its own behalf, not on behalf of users
  • • You're building backend services, APIs, or automation tools
  • • You can securely store client credentials on a server

Real-World Use Cases

Here are practical examples of when to use each OAuth 2.0 flow in real-world applications:

Use Case 1: Social Media Web Application

Scenario: A web application where users sign in with Google or GitHub to access their profile, post content, and interact with other users.

Flow: Authorization Code with PKCE

Why: Users need to authenticate and grant permissions. The app acts on behalf of users to access their data. Refresh tokens enable long-lived sessions without requiring users to log in repeatedly.

Use Case 2: Microservices Architecture

Scenario: A payment service needs to call an inventory service to check stock levels before processing orders. Both services are part of the same system.

Flow: Client Credentials

Why: No user is involved - this is pure service-to-service communication. Each service has its own credentials and authenticates independently. Simple, secure, and performant for backend services.

Use Case 3: Mobile Banking App

Scenario: A mobile banking app where users log in to view their accounts, make transfers, and pay bills.

Flow: Authorization Code with PKCE

Why: Mobile apps are public clients that can't securely store secrets. PKCE provides security without requiring a client secret. Users authenticate and the app acts on their behalf to access banking services.

Use Case 4: Scheduled Data Sync Job

Scenario: A cron job that runs nightly to sync customer data between your CRM and data warehouse via their APIs.

Flow: Client Credentials

Why: No user interaction is possible in a scheduled job. The job acts on its own behalf to sync data between systems. Client Credentials provides simple, secure authentication for automated processes.

Use Case 5: Single-Page Application (SPA)

Scenario: A React dashboard that displays analytics data from an API, where users log in to see their personalized data.

Flow: Authorization Code with PKCE

Why: SPAs are public clients, so PKCE is essential. Authorization Code with PKCE is more secure than the deprecated Implicit flow. Modern browsers support CORS for token exchange, making this the recommended approach.

Use Case 6: CLI Developer Tool

Scenario: A command-line tool that developers use to deploy applications to a cloud platform.

Flow: Client Credentials (for service accounts) or Device Flow (for user accounts)

Why: For service accounts, use Client Credentials. For user-specific actions, use Device Flow (a variant of Authorization Code for devices without browsers). The choice depends on whether actions are service-specific or user-specific.

Documenting OAuth Flows with AutEng

AutEng makes it easy to create comprehensive OAuth documentation with Mermaid sequence diagrams, comparison tables, and code examples. Here's how this page was created:

1. Sequence Diagrams

All the sequence diagrams on this page were created using Mermaid syntax. AutEng renders them in real-time as you type:

Creating OAuth Sequence Diagrams

Mermaid makes it easy to visualize authentication flows

Rendering diagram...

2. Comparison Tables

Use markdown tables to create side-by-side comparisons. AutEng renders them with proper styling:

Creating Comparison Tables

Markdown tables for clear feature comparisons

FeatureAuth CodeClient Credentials
User Involved✅ Yes❌ No
Refresh Tokens✅ Yes❌ No
Use CaseWeb/Mobile AppsBackend Services

3. Code Examples

Include working code examples in multiple languages. AutEng provides syntax highlighting and copy functionality:

Adding Code Examples

Syntax-highlighted code blocks with language specification

# OAuth 2.0 Client Credentials Example
import requests

response = requests.post(
    'https://auth.example.com/token',
    data={
        'grant_type': 'client_credentials',
        'client_id': 'your_client_id',
        'client_secret': 'your_client_secret'
    }
)

token = response.json()['access_token']

Why AutEng for OAuth Documentation?

  • Real-time Preview: See your diagrams and code as you write
  • Mermaid Support: Built-in support for sequence diagrams, flowcharts, and more
  • Syntax Highlighting: Automatic highlighting for 100+ programming languages
  • Version Control: Track changes to your authentication documentation
  • Collaboration: Share documentation with your team via public links
  • AI Generation: Generate diagrams and code examples with AI assistance

Related Content

Ready to Start?

Start creating beautiful technical documentation with AutEng.

Get Started with AutEng